The second in a six-part series in which the authors, Allie Goldstein and Kirsten Howard, recent graduate students from the University of Michigan’s School of Natural Resources and Environment, tour the United States, uncovering stories of people preparing for life in a changing climate.
When most people think of climate change, the first consequence that crosses their minds is heat. One antidote, as we learned in Baltimore, is shade. We visited Baltimore on our climate resilience road trip because Kristin Baja, a fellow alumna from the University of Michigan’s School of Natural Resources, was just hired as the city’s Hazard Mitigation and Adaptation Planner—the only person we know of anywhere with that title. Part of Baja’s job is to keep people safe (read: cool) in a city with a growing urban heat island effect that disproportionately impacts low-income, treeless neighborhoods. Driving around Baltimore, we saw some blocks where the only shade came from the thin shadows of buildings. On others, though, new saplings were growing strong—part of the city’s effort to double its canopy over the next twenty-five years. Baja is working hard to plant trees where they are most needed; she showed us that urban canopy is not just a climate change adaptation tool, but also a measure of environmental justice. Growing an urban forest is a kind of endurance sport, but we’re hopeful that Baltimore is in it for the long haul.
—Allie and Kirsten
Baltimore is known as the “city of neighborhoods.” Kristin Baja, the new Hazard Mitigation and Adaptation Planner for the city, is working on learning the names of all 225 of them. She’s eight months into the job and doing pretty well so far—as we drive around the city, she’s rattling off names: Patterson Park, the Middle East, Four By Four (a four block by four block square), Oliver, Ellwood Park. Easier than memorizing neighborhoods, though, is figuring out what areas of the city are in need of more tree canopy. These are the areas with no shade during extreme heat events.
“We’re conducting a vulnerability assessment to help inform our planning process; however it’s pretty obvious which neighborhoods are in need of trees just by walking through them,” Baja said.
We’re driving down streets that are completely devoid of canopy. It’s around five o’clock, and the buildings are casting square shadows on the streets. Midday, though, there’s no hiding from the sun.
Trees where they’re most needed
To address the tree canopy shortage, in 2006, then-mayor Martin O’Malley set a goal to double the urban tree canopy (how much of the city’s area is literally shaded by trees) to 40 percent by 2037. With the current canopy at 27.4 percent, the city is trying to coordinate both public and private tree planting efforts under the umbrella of TreeBaltimore, run by the Department of Recreation and Parks’ Urban Forestry Division. An important part of this effort is to ensure that new trees are planted where they are most needed. Many are going into the ground already, at a rate of three thousand per year since 2009.
“The urban heat island is a big problem in Baltimore. The tree canopy is extremely limited the closer you get to city’s core,” Baja told us.
The urban heat island effect occurs when built-up areas absorb more heat than the surrounding rural areas. In 2008, an analysis by NASA showed that Baltimore’s land surface temperature can be as much as fifty degrees Fahrenheit hotter in the city center when compared to the surrounding temperate forest. Without accounting for the heat index, the city’s Climate Action Plan predicts that Baltimore will experience between fifteen and thirty-five days over one hundred degrees by 2100, as compared to the average five days per year at the end of the twentieth century. These predictions are especially concerning for Baltimore’s vulnerable population of elderly, poor, and homeless residents.
Tree canopies can lower direct temperatures up to nine degrees Fahrenheit, and they have many additional benefits. They absorb air pollutants and stormwater, plus they cool buildings, reducing energy bills. Canopy can also make neighborhoods safer. A 2012 study showed that a 10 percent increase in Baltimore’s tree canopy corresponded to a 12 percent reduction in the neighborhood crime rate. A young resident of North Luzerne Avenue told Baja that the trees recently planted on the block had changed the way people in her community were talking to each other, and that she actually felt safer.
Not all tree-huggers
Despite the many benefits that urban canopies provide, there are a few big challenges when it comes to getting trees in the ground. “In some areas people don’t want trees. They think more trees will result in more debris that they’re responsible for cleaning up,” Baja told us.
Keeping trees healthy is also a challenge. Of the 2.6 million trees in Baltimore, more than one quarter are distressed, dead, or dying, according to the U.S. Forest Service. As we drove through one neighborhood, Baja commented that a few young trees looked like they were in rough shape, even though the building next door was supposed to be maintaining them. To nurse trees back to health, the Baltimore Treekeepers, a group of about forty volunteers, conducts trainings and tree maintenance around the city.
“We are focusing on continued outreach in urban heat island neighborhoods, collaborating with community leaders to educate people about the long-term benefits of trees,” Baja said.
If not shade, safety
Growing an urban tree canopy is inherently a long-term proposition. In the shorter term, the city of Baltimore is figuring out how to keep residents cool as the days get hotter. The Code Red Program started in 2008 as a special project run by the Baltimore City Health Department. Days that register 105 degrees Fahrenheit on the Heat Index are designated Code Red Heat Alert days. On these days, community action centers and senior centers around the city serve as cooling centers—essentially large, public air-conditioned spaces where the Maryland Food Bank provides free bottled water.
“Last year we had seventeen Code Red Alert days, and I expect to see as many or more in future years,” said Jennifer Martin, the Deputy Director of the Health Department’s Office of Public Health Preparedness and Response. “The need for this type of response program is not going away any time soon.”
According to Martin, hundreds of people used the cooling centers last summer, but there are many more who could benefit from accessing them. In addition to a lack of media access, limited transportation and people’s underestimation of the cumulative effects of heat stress keep them from going to the centers.
“A lot of it comes down to people’s attitudes—they say ‘I’ve been through hot summer before,’” Martin explained. “And some people don’t like the idea of coming to a cooling center during the day, getting comfortable, and then having to go back home and get uncomfortable.”
Heat-related deaths are tricky to diagnose, but in 2012, at least thirteen people died from heat-related causes in Baltimore. This year, the health department is focusing on getting the word out, especially during multi-day heat waves. In addition to an official launch of the 2013 Code Red season on a hot day in May, Code Red information is shared with 311 information line call takers, health department outreach workers, Community Emergency Response Team volunteers, and the Mayor’s Office of Neighborhoods to improve the reach of public messages to stay safe in the heat. During extreme heat or extended heat waves, Reverse 911 can send automated messages recorded by the mayor to all residential landlines.
Seeing both the forest and the trees
Martin emphasizes that Code Red is an emergency response program—it’s not intended to mitigate the urban heat island effect, but rather respond to its impacts. However, the program is part of Baltimore’s new effort to combine hazard mitigation and climate change adaptation planning by overlaying planning for natural hazards, like heat, with an understanding of how those hazards might change in the future. Baltimore is one of the first cities in the country to marry these two concepts, and the planning department has secured a year-and-a-half of funding for the effort, which engages officials across the city.
By the time the plan is complete, Baja should have mastered the names of all 225 neighborhoods in Baltimore, and the city’s recently planted saplings should be a year-and-a-half stronger.
Allie Goldstein and Kirsten Howard will be on the road through late summer. Learn more about their trip at www.adaptionstories.com.
Cool! I used to live in Baltimore and can attest that there a lot of great people doing great (and needed) work there. Shout out to Remington and Patterson Park!
Great!i would like to live here.
It is September 11 and about 90 degrees and downtown where I work there are a couple of small groves (Lombard and Gay)but as pointed out in the blog, there is a lot of blight.
You also reminded me that Tree Baltimore has not contacted me for volunteer work in a long time. I’ll have to get back on their list of volunteers.